Shopping

My wide calves make finding knee-high boots a hassle, but these are the wear-tested pairs I’d shop now

By Josefin Forsberg

Photo: Josefin Forsberg

A knee-high boot can carry a skirt through winter, keep slush off your ankles, and dress up the plainest jeans. Getting a pair past your calves is another matter, as editor (and former horse girl who could never zip up a pair of riding boots) Josefin Forsberg knows all too well. Below, she shares the pairs worth investing in this season – fit (almost) guaranteed

All products featured on Vogue Scandinavia are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

I am fundamentally fashion over function when it comes to footwear. I will happily wear Havaianas well into the October chill, a habit my mother has long lamented, warning it will most likely end in frostbite. But even I won’t budge on the usefulness of a great pair of knee-high boots. An ankle boot may handle the odd wet day. A knee-high offers proper ankle protection and will keep any rogue slush from biting your exposed ankle or soaking your socks. Come the Nordic winter, that is no small virtue.

Shopping for them, however, is another matter. I’m far from alone in living with athletic calves that make sourcing a pair of knee-high boots a somewhat horrific experience. Blame mine on genetics, or on how I spent my childhood. As a horse girl who passed most afternoons in the stable, I was deeply jealous of the riders who could squeeze into gorgeous riding boots or chaps. Mine refused to zip up, so argyle socks and jodhpurs it was.

Editor Josefin Forsberg wears black knee-high boots, a trench coat and a cow-printed pony hair bag on the streets of Stockholm

Photo: Josefin Forsberg

When I went hunting for knee-highs of my own, I shed many tears trying to squeeze into skinny boots. The ideal leg back then belonged to Kate Moss and her skinny-jeaned cohort, and mine looked nothing like theirs. What that harrowing experience has given me, though, is the expertise to guide you towards the right boot, whatever your legs look like.

Below are the knee-high boots worth investing in this season (accounting for most of the ways a tall boot can go wrong). Each has been chosen for the details that decide fit: shaft sizing, calf measurements you can check before you buy, and materials built for a Nordic winter.

The best black knee-high boots

I think that, as with a little black dress, everyone should own a pair of black knee-high boots. It’s the sort of capsule-wardrobe essential that is endlessly versatile, with endless ways to make it your own. Matte or patent? Or perhaps pony hair? Then there’s the height of the heel, the shape of the toecap, and whether the shaft is slouchy, structured, or stovepipe-straight.

If you want my advice, opt for a classic leather look with a slightly wider shaft (to allow for stuffing your trousers into them), a structured mid-height heel, and a slightly pointed toe. They’re superbly flattering for any leg and any look. And if you, like me, have struggled to find a tall boot that fits the bill, skip ahead to the wide-calf section.


The oot black pony hair knee high boots - Dagmar - On a white background
Boot black pony hair

Dagmar

SHOP NOWEUR 814
The best black croc knee high boots - Cesare Gaspari - On a white background
Croc queen knee high boots

Cesare Gaspari

SHOP NOWEUR 447
The best glossy leather knee high boots - Arket - On a white background
Glossy leather boots

Arket

SHOP NOWEUR 329
The best leather knee high boots with stretch shaft - Massimo Dutti - On a white background
Leather boots with stretch shaft

Massimo Dutti

SHOP NOWEUR 243

The best brown knee-high boots

As with black, the right brown comes down to taste. For anyone who prefers a more timeless look, chocolate brown is slightly more wearable than tan. I’m particularly fond of cognac, though that may be a divisive opinion. Whichever shade you land on, I think the best brown tall boots are made from suede: the matte material makes the colour come alive, so it looks truly rich.

Another perhaps controversial opinion: I’m getting tired of black. That fatigue has led me to explore alternative neutrals, and brown is hard to beat. It helps that chocolate is one of the colours of the season. Pair it with navy, true-blue denim, khaki, and beige for a luxe and luscious colour palette that feels warmer than head-to-toe black.


The best wedge knee high boots - Dico - On a white background
Liv wedge calfskin knee high boots

Dico Copenhagen

SHOP NOWEUR 409
Sarconi cannella Leather knee high boots - ATP Atelier - On a white background
Sarconi cannella leather knee high boots

ATP Atelier

SHOP NOWEUR 675
The best brown knee high riding boots - Na-Kd - On a white background
Straight leather riding boots

NA-KD

SHOP NOWEUR 86
The best brown suede knee high boots - Isabel Marant - On a white background
Elita draped suede knee-high boots

Isabel Marant

SHOP NOWEUR 890

The best suede knee-high boots

Suede is divisive as a winter boot, because Nordic winter has a tendency to do its worst. I have lost a pair to road salt, and it was heartbreaking. These days I protect-spray religiously, starting before the very first wear, but the only surefire way to keep suede spotless is to reserve it for dry autumn days… or for after the ice and snow have all but gone.

So when shopping, think of suede as a two-season investment rather than a winter workhorse, and check whether the pair has been treated to repel water. And make sure to enjoy its second act: I especially adore an early-spring swap-around, when suede boots come out of storage to be worn with swishy boho dresses, chunky knitwear, and a leather jacket.


The best suede knee-high boots

The best brown suede knee high boots - Blankens - On a white background
The michelle chocolate brown suede

Blankens

SHOP NOWEUR 405
The best brown suede wedge knee high boots - Zara
Knee high boots with wedge heel

Zara

SHOP NOWEUR 116
The best heeled suede knee-high boots - Veronica Beard - On a white background
Lisa suede knee-high boots

Veronica Beard

SHOP NOWEUR 685
The best heeled brown suede knee high boots with fur trim - Mango - On a white background
Suede boot with fur trim

Mango

SHOP NOWEUR 243

The best heeled knee-high boots

If you ask me, any heel is a walkable heel. I say that as someone who has, on the odd occasion, tripped and slipped her way through a chaotic snowstorm in heeled ankle boots and ankle-breaking court shoes. Still, I do think there’s a sweet spot somewhere between a kitten and a proper stiletto, and Anonymous Copenhagen has found it with Valle 50. Handily, the Danish brand names its boots after their heel height in millimetres, so a Valle 50 has a 50-millimetre stiletto – aka the perfect heel height.

I’m a firm believer in kitten-heel knee-high boots, and the kitten heel is having a moment this season, knee-high styles included. But a western block heel can be persuasive. A chunky heel is useful and secure underfoot, but it can look clunky if the boot itself isn’t proportioned to match, so look for a shaft and toe that carry the same visual weight as the heel.


The best black leather heeled knee high boots - Bared Footwear - On a white background
Pintail black leather knee high boots

Bared Footwear

SHOP NOWEUR 461
The best calf hair tiger heeled knee high boots -Anonymous Copenhagen - On a white background
Valle 50 stiletto calf hair tiger

Anonymous Copenhagen

SHOP NOWEUR 392
The best heeled suede knee high boots with buckle - Staud - On a white background
Wally buckled suede knee boots

Staud

SHOP NOWEUR 324
The best burgundy heeled leather knee high boots - & Other Stories - On a white background
Knee-high leather boots

& Other Stories

SHOP NOWEUR 269

The best flat knee-high boots

I don’t own a pair of flat riding boots, and I still lament my childhood riding-boot experience. But with equestrian references cantering through the fashion industry, I’m considering this winter my comeback. Hermès sent jodhpurs and flat-heeled riding boots down its autumn/winter '26 runway, and knee-high riding boots were also central at Proenza Schouler and Tory Burch. Childhood me would have been thrilled. As for the look, I don’t want mine to look like they’re made to muck out the stables. I’ll be looking for dressage-inspired knee-high riding boots with a skinny buckle and deliciously dainty details.


The best leather knee-high ridning boots - Aeyde - On a white background
Hector knee-high boots

Aeyde

SHOP NOWEUR 695
Bukled suede boots

Mango

SHOP NOWEUR 117
The best flat leather knee high boots - COS - On a white background
Pointed knee-high leather boots

COS

SHOP NOWEUR 292
Karola boots dark brown crinkle leather

Miista

SHOP NOWEUR 520

The best wide-calf knee-high boots

I still remember the first pair of knee-highs that fit. They weren’t the second-skin fit I wanted (slouchy around the ankle), but they slipped on and I was beyond pleased. It was a magical experience. Getting there taught me, the hard way, that wide-fit and wide-calf fit are not the same thing. Wide-fit refers to the foot; wide-calf refers to a shaft cut to a calf measurement. Wide-shaft styles are something else again: roomy by design, but not necessarily sized to anyone’s leg.

The only way to truly know whether a tall boot will fit is to try it on in person or measure your calf. Both are tedious tasks, but worth it. To measure properly, wrap a measuring tape around the fullest part of your calf, ideally over whatever you’ll wear underneath, and check that the number is smaller than both the boot opening and the shaft circumference the brand lists.

Over the years, I’ve come to terms with the fact that most of my boots will need to be slouchy. Today, though, I have an arsenal of knee-high boots with the perfect fit, and a few brands make that far easier to find. Vagabond’s Blanca comes in two shaft widths, with the wider even slouching around my almost-an-athlete legs. The real revelation, though, is Sania D’Mina’s new Nine, a classic black tall boot with a skinny nine-centimetre heel and a shaft that comes in five sizes, from XS to XL, chosen independently of your shoe size. A size 38 foot is no longer stuck with a size 38 calf, which is good news for slim calves, too. The ideal fit, especially on such a timeless model, makes the investment worth it.


The best black leather wide-calf knee-high boots - Sania D'mina  - On a white background
Nine L black leather

Sania D'mina

SHOP NOWEUR 1387
The best brown leather heeled wide-calf knee-high boots - Mango - On a white background
Leather heeled boots

Mango

SHOP NOWEUR 171
The best brown leather wide-calf knee-high boots - Vagabond - On a white background
Blanca boots

Vagabond

SHOP NOWEUR 234
The best burgundy shiny leather wide-calf knee-high boots - H&M - On a white background
Knee-high boots

H&M

SHOP NOWEUR 72

What to wear with knee-high boots?

Almost anything: there’s no one true way to wear a knee-high boot. It’s a basic, and it’s particularly fabulous for extending the life of your summer clothes well into winter. Emulate Carolyn Bessette Kennedy with a knee-length pencil skirt, black boots, and a slim-fit roll-neck. Or wear your Bermuda shorts with a slouchy sweater and a large coat. A funky print or texture will dress up the simplest look, including a little black dress, or straight jeans and a T-shirt.

My colleague Linnéa Pesonen styles her boots beautifully with a knitted knee-high sock, a gorgeous way to bring texture into a tonal look. As for me, slim skirts and velvet jackets with frog closures are my go-to this season.

Are knee-high boots still in style?

Yes. Knee-high boots are a wardrobe basic rather than a passing trend, and the AW26 runways made the case for them in every register. At Acne Studios, which marked its 30th anniversary at the Collège des Bernardins in Paris, fur-trimmed stretch boots climbed the leg, worn over psychedelic-patterned leggings. Chloé went chunkier and western-inspired, pairing its boots with messy hair and frilly full-length dresses. And Hermès, the ultimate horse-girl brand, sent out tonal looks top to toe with equestrian flair.

How should knee-high boots fit?

Knee-high boots should close comfortably around the fullest part of your calf, with room for tights or jeans underneath but no gaping. Measure your calf rather than relying on your shoe size, since shaft fit and foot fit don’t always go together. A shaft that stops a few centimetres short of the knee lets your joints move without the top digging in. For calves at either end of the scale, look for brands that size the shaft separately from the foot. Sania D’Mina’s Nine runs from XS to XL, and Dutch specialist JJ Footwear makes boots in calf widths from 30 to 60 centimetres.

How do you keep knee-high boots from slipping down?

Most of the time, a boot slips because the shaft is too wide for your calf, so the first fix is a pair sized to your calf rather than your foot. If a pair you already own gapes, fill the space: a knitted knee-high sock adds grip and bulk, and adds some interesting texture.